The Milburn Review has set out proposals to tackle the growing number of young people who are out of education, employment or training, recognising poor health as a major barrier to opportunity. Poor health can shape a young person’s chances long before they enter the workforce. Academy Fellows argue that improving health, tackling poverty and providing support earlier in life must be central to the solution.

Academy Fellow, Professor David Taylor-Robinson FMedSci is Academic Director of Health Equity North. Last year in their analysis, Estimating the savings and financial benefits to the UK government of return-to-work for people in receipt of Universal Credit, Health Equity North argued that effective return-to-work programmes should combine employment support with action on the underlying health challenges that prevent people from entering and remaining in work, particularly in areas experiencing high levels of deprivation and ill health.

Following the publication of the Department for Work and Pensions’ From a Welfare State to a Working State: a new settlement for the next generation report Professor David Taylor-Robinson FMedSci said: "Milburn’s review makes clear how much we have underinvested in young people. It is right to put poor health at the centre of the problem, and I welcome its proposals to invest in health and education and give young people more ways into work, including apprenticeships, work placements and subsidised jobs. We need to prevent ill health where we can and support children as soon as difficulties emerge.

"Our Child of the North research shows that children who grow up in poverty are much more likely to experience poor mental and physical health. They are also more likely to spend time out of education, employment or training as young adults. Poverty and cuts to the services families rely on make it harder for children to thrive at school and for young people to find and stay in work. Today’s review looks to Denmark and the Netherlands for lessons on youth employment, but it is also worth looking at child poverty in these countries. Before housing costs, around one in ten children in Denmark and the Netherlands live in relative poverty – about half the rate in the UK.

"Reducing child poverty further has to be part of any serious plan to bring down the number of young people out of education, employment or training. The government estimates that removing the two-child limit has already lifted around 300,000 children out of poverty. That is a welcome start – but we need sustained investment from the early years, through school and into adulthood. That means helping families afford the essentials, getting children support when difficulties first emerge, and making sure that support continues as young people move into training or work.

"The review counts on future welfare savings to offset part of the cost of investing in young people. The gamble is that some young people could lose income before that investment improves their lives. Young people whose health and education have already been affected by years of hardship need both better services and enough income to live on. Cutting their benefits risks deepening the hardship that contributed to their poor health and making it harder for them to take up the very opportunities the review proposes."

Responses from additional Academy Fellows

Professor Yvonne Doyle CB FMedSci said: "Today's Milburn Review identifies the need to offer life opportunities to young persons. Research from the Academy of Medical Sciences and UK Royal Colleges show that children are underserved in the UK in their health and development in relevant country comparisons. Furthermore, the child health workforce has been reduced in times of austerity, further compromising young people chances of good health outcomes and engagement with society. It is crucial that there is support and development for the young people who may be most vulnerable following these experiences so that they can truly realise their potential in life and for the UK economy."


Professor Petra Meier FMedSci said: “The ambition of the Milburn review is welcome. Too many young people are becoming disconnected from education and work, often after health, educational and social difficulties have accumulated over time. The proposal to intervene earlier and guarantee meaningful opportunities alongside health and practical support could make a real difference.

But the sequencing matters. Opportunities and support need to be genuinely available before changes are made to young people’s benefits. Moving faster on reducing financial support than on building the education, health and employment support around young people risks transferring the consequences of system failures onto those least able to absorb them.

This is also a question about what kind of future is being created for the next generation. Success should mean healthier young people moving into sustained education and decent work, with greater security, agency and opportunities to progress. That requires long-term commitment from government, employers and public services, and investment in the skills and opportunities needed for a healthier, fairer and more sustainable economy.”

Further reading

Our Fellows’ responses reflect the importance of preventing poor health and improving health outcomes throughout people’s lives, including the role of prevention.

Supporting young people's health is also an investment in their future participation in society and the economy, highlighting the importance of recognising the wider value of health interventions.